Government Accuses Columbia Gem House of Tax Evasion
Malawi’s government has made a staggering demand of $309 billion in unpaid taxes and royalties from Columbia Gem House, a US-based gemstone company.
This claim pertains to rubies allegedly exported over a decade. Malawi’s Attorney General, Thabo Chakaka Nyirenda, stated, “Some of the evidence we’ll use comes from Columbia Gem House itself, including declarations made in the US.”
However, Columbia Gem House has dismissed these allegations as “baseless and defamatory.” The company argued that Malawi’s claims implied an impossible scale of gemstone exports. “They haven’t done this by any stretch of the imagination,” it noted in an official statement. 
Nyirenda countered this defense, asserting that the company underreported ruby export values and allegedly altered the ownership details of Nyala Mines, where it sourced gemstones.
Dispute with TotalEnergies Over Oil Storage Revenues
Adding to its efforts, Malawi seeks $4 billion from French multinational TotalEnergies. The dispute centers on a 2001 agreement, under which TotalEnergies was to supply fuel and share profits equally.
Nyirenda alleged, “The company only paid for two years and stopped in 2006.” Legal proceedings are underway in Malawi to address the issue.
Tobacco Trade Controversy with Star Agritech International
In another case, Malawi is pursuing $9.5 million from Star Agritech International, a Turkish tobacco firm. The government claims the company acquired three million tonnes of tobacco in 2013 but failed to pay the full amount. The Hong Kong court ruled in favor of Malawi Leaf Company, a state-owned enterprise, proving the owed amount.
Star Agritech International refuted the accusations, insisting that the transaction involved only $5 million worth of substandard tobacco. “This is completely wrong and represents challenges businesses face when operating in Africa,” remarked Iqbal Lambat, the firm’s CEO.
Economic Woes Drive Aggressive Revenue Claims
Malawi’s financial challenges, including a $1.2 billion national debt, have compelled it to intensify revenue collection efforts. Economist Wisdom Mgomezulu suggested that financial strain might explain the government’s assertive approach.
“They’re looking at all potential sources of income, but these claims are disproportionate to the economy’s size,” he observed.
Multinational Disputes Across Africa
Malawi’s aggressive stance mirrors actions taken by other African nations. For example, Mali recently issued an arrest warrant for Barrick Gold’s CEO over $500 million in unpaid taxes. Similarly, an Australian mining company, Resolute Mining, settled a $160 million tax dispute with Mali’s junta in November.
Will Malawi’s Claims Bolster Its Economy?
As the disputes unfold, Malawi’s pursuit of unpaid revenues could set a precedent for resource-rich nations confronting multinational corporations. With mining contributing just 1% to its GDP, Malawi aims to expand the sector and reduce reliance on foreign bailouts.
How do you think Malawi’s aggressive revenue drive will reshape its economic landscape? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Read More:
